Skip to content
stratum+tcp://stratum.testnet5.com:3333· user: your tb1 address · pass: xSetup guide →
Testnet5.com
Testnet5.com › Fair mining

Fair mining: what is fixed in Testnet5

Earlier Bitcoin testnets had a special mining rule that rewarded people who knew how to game it. Testnet5 removes that rule, so every block takes real proof of work, just like mainnet.

The old rule: difficulty 1 after 20 minutes

Testnet3 had a rule that let a block be mined at the minimum difficulty if its timestamp was more than 20 minutes after the previous block. Testnet4 kept that rule in a modified form [BIP 94]. The idea was to let developers occasionally mine a block on a laptop [Poinsot, bitcoindev].

In practice the rule became a loophole. As Antoine Poinsot put it on the bitcoindev mailing list, testnet4 tried to be both permissionless and friendly to laptop miners, and "As a result it failed on both count: it neither mimics mainnet nor allows developers to mine active blocks on their laptop." [Unbreaking testnet4]

How people who knew the trick gamed it

  • Block storms on Testnet3. BIP 94 notes that three years' worth of Testnet3 blocks were mined in a few weeks during block storms, which made the network practically unusable [BIP 94] [Lopp].
  • Clock tricks on Testnet4. Sjors Provoost described CPU miners moving their computer clock forward 20 minutes, again and again, up to the two-hour future limit, so "when a real difficulty block appears, you may see 5 blocks on top of it instantly." [Provoost, bitcoindev]
  • Constant small reorgs. BIP 95 says the Testnet4 exception "had been systematically and persistently exploited" shortly after launch, leaving the network with constant reorgs of a few blocks as difficulty-exception blocks competed for the tip [BIP 95].
  • Most blocks were cheap blocks. Anthony Towns counted 192 real-difficulty blocks and 1,824 minimum-difficulty blocks between Testnet4 heights 135,072 and 137,087, and concluded that about 90% of Testnet4 blocks were won by network-propagation races rather than hashrate [Towns, bitcoindev].

Empty blocks and unconfirmed transactions

The race for cheap blocks got so intense that some miners started sending empty blocks, because they propagate faster. A Delving Bitcoin proposal summed it up: "The result is a network of miners where most blocks do not confirm any transactions. This defeats the purpose of a test network." [Delving Bitcoin]

A Bitcoin Core pull request from April 2026 described about 85 to 90% of Testnet4 blocks as CPU-mined minimum-difficulty blocks, with transactions confirmed only in the remaining ASIC blocks, which averaged about one hour apart [PR #35081].

Users noticed. On the bitcoindev mailing list in July 2026, Ali Sherief wrote that his Testnet4 faucet transactions sat in the mempool "for around 30-60 minutes, never confirm, and then drop out." [bitcoindev]

Fixes for Testnet4 itself were proposed, including a hard fork (Bitcoin Core PR #34420) and a soft fork (PR #35081), but both pull requests were closed without being merged [PR #34420] [PR #35081]. The developers chose a fresh network instead, partly because changing Testnet4's rules would take a long time and might be disrupted by the same people exploiting it [BIP 95].

What Testnet5 changes

  • No difficulty exception at all. "In Testnet 5 there is no exception to the PoW rules," because any such exception could be exploited by a motivated attacker [BIP 95].
  • Higher minimum difficulty. The proof-of-work limit is 0x1a0fffff, a minimum difficulty of about 1,000,000 (1,048,561 when calculated exactly). BIP 95 says this dampens quick mining of many blocks right after launch while still letting a handful of home miners or a single ASIC keep the network usable [BIP 95].
  • BIP 54 Consensus Cleanup from block 1. This fixes the timewarp attack, caps signature operations per transaction, makes 64-byte transactions invalid, and requires unique coinbase transactions [BIP 54]. See our BIP 54 explainer.
  • Mainnet rules otherwise. All consensus rules active on mainnet as of May 2026 are enforced from block 1, including Taproot [BIP 95].
  • A fair launch. The genesis block commits to mainnet block 975,744, so it could not be mined before that block existed, and it was mined through a public 0%-fee solo pool so there was no private pre-mine [launch email] [bootstrap notes].

Our pool's stance: no empty blocks

Testnet5.com builds every block from Bitcoin Core's getblocktemplate and includes the transactions the node gives us. We do not mine empty blocks on purpose. If your transaction is valid and paying a normal fee, our blocks are built to confirm it.

Mined some test coins? See the testnet markets on AltQuick.

AltQuick lists Bitcoin Testnet4 (TBTC4) and Bitcoin Signet (SBTC).

Open AltQuick

Sources